vanishing winds......
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Jaded-Raven Wrote:
I apologize for being insulting, it was unnecessary.
You speak of being immature and unintelligent - I find people being so when they don't think their ideas through before posting them. You say the plant idea just popped into your head and then you posted it on the forums. And your arguements were "Jade is green and she debuted in the Living Forest". I honestly felt like slamming my head into a wall, because seriously, that is not well-thought through at all!
However, I am sorry for not having been more constructive about my criticism. I should not have exploded like I did.
I do hope you understand the context of my critique though.
Zmoke Wrote:
It's not about whether you handle a discussion about an idea or not, it's about the freedom of giving out your ideas. If the idea is fragile, give it space and let it be. You can give an opinion of your own on that, but that doesn't mean you can come to insult the one who made that idea. I and noobsmoke_mk have done nothing to you, huh? Once you've told your opinion, that's it. It's received. No need to pull off a huge two-page argument on that. And from looking how your arguments were primarily based on insulting, maybe it's you who can't handle a discussion. I don't care if the plant moves fit for Jade or not, it was merely an idea. I didn't think it would necessarily be great, it just came up and I decided to post it, to have a wider opinion on that. I posted it to see if people may find facts supporting the idea rather than you trying to see all its downsides.
Zmoke Wrote: "You don't go to bash on a rising artist by trying to find all the flaws from their artwork either just because you like the concept it's based on, do you?"
Jaded-Raven: "If the idea is fragile, it will break."
Nice to know. It will break, by whom? As a matter of fact, new and innovative ideas are always fragile.
Jaded-Raven Wrote:
And my answer to that was:
And my answer to that was:
Jaded-Raven Wrote:
Oh please, it's not because of the idea about Smoke and Jade, it's the whole "Jade wants to smoke his pole" thing that makes me think of him as disgusting. I cannot and will not take people like that seriously, so sorry if that offends you.
I might come off as harsh and critisizing, but only towards those who do not take the main topic seriously. If you have an idea and you want to present it, then come with some good arguements for how the idea could work! Then I shall respect it. However, neither of you succeeded in doing so, and so I come with my hammer of judgement.
There was no legit reasons Jade would ever have "plant powers", but from what I read in the Smoke thread, there were actually some good ideas about the Smoke/Jade romance. I might be against the whole romance idea, but they had some good arguements for it. And then noobsmoke_mk provides us with some disgusting sicko pervert comments about it which made me lose all respect towards him. And he's done so about other topics as well which makes me wonder if he simply trolls or if he is truly serious about it. Whatever the case, then I cannot and will not take him seriously because of it.
If the idea is fragile, it will break. And if you can't handle the discussions on a message board like this, then don't post in it.
That said, I am all in for innovative ideas. But give the ideas some ground when presenting them!
Oh please, it's not because of the idea about Smoke and Jade, it's the whole "Jade wants to smoke his pole" thing that makes me think of him as disgusting. I cannot and will not take people like that seriously, so sorry if that offends you.
I might come off as harsh and critisizing, but only towards those who do not take the main topic seriously. If you have an idea and you want to present it, then come with some good arguements for how the idea could work! Then I shall respect it. However, neither of you succeeded in doing so, and so I come with my hammer of judgement.
There was no legit reasons Jade would ever have "plant powers", but from what I read in the Smoke thread, there were actually some good ideas about the Smoke/Jade romance. I might be against the whole romance idea, but they had some good arguements for it. And then noobsmoke_mk provides us with some disgusting sicko pervert comments about it which made me lose all respect towards him. And he's done so about other topics as well which makes me wonder if he simply trolls or if he is truly serious about it. Whatever the case, then I cannot and will not take him seriously because of it.
If the idea is fragile, it will break. And if you can't handle the discussions on a message board like this, then don't post in it.
That said, I am all in for innovative ideas. But give the ideas some ground when presenting them!
It's not about whether you handle a discussion about an idea or not, it's about the freedom of giving out your ideas. If the idea is fragile, give it space and let it be. You can give an opinion of your own on that, but that doesn't mean you can come to insult the one who made that idea. I and noobsmoke_mk have done nothing to you, huh? Once you've told your opinion, that's it. It's received. No need to pull off a huge two-page argument on that. And from looking how your arguments were primarily based on insulting, maybe it's you who can't handle a discussion. I don't care if the plant moves fit for Jade or not, it was merely an idea. I didn't think it would necessarily be great, it just came up and I decided to post it, to have a wider opinion on that. I posted it to see if people may find facts supporting the idea rather than you trying to see all its downsides.
Zmoke Wrote: "You don't go to bash on a rising artist by trying to find all the flaws from their artwork either just because you like the concept it's based on, do you?"
Jaded-Raven: "If the idea is fragile, it will break."
Nice to know. It will break, by whom? As a matter of fact, new and innovative ideas are always fragile.
I apologize for being insulting, it was unnecessary.
You speak of being immature and unintelligent - I find people being so when they don't think their ideas through before posting them. You say the plant idea just popped into your head and then you posted it on the forums. And your arguements were "Jade is green and she debuted in the Living Forest". I honestly felt like slamming my head into a wall, because seriously, that is not well-thought through at all!
However, I am sorry for not having been more constructive about my criticism. I should not have exploded like I did.
I do hope you understand the context of my critique though.
I don't see it immature if you post an idea you haven't thought through, not sure about unintelligent (:see next column). I intended the post purely so that if people like it, they adapt with it, if not, then it shall be left behind and I would've forgotten it right there barring if I thought it through afterwards seeing it sensible overall.
Why I posted the idea right there was because peculiar ideas in the first place (can be compared to inventions) should be written down or told to somebody so you can further investigate your idea with a wider aspect and see if it could work. It could be a bad idea, or, it could be a revolutionary idea - that shall never see the light in case you didn't take care of it ultimately forgetting it.
The reason why I mentioned the Living Forest thing was because NRS often tends to leave things open, so that they can expand even a minor thing much further in the future - and, leaving fans to speculate, which seems to be working. Plants could work with a new character rather - as we have sorted out.
I understand your context of critique, got your point by now entirely. Apologize is accepted. You're the only fellow Nordic MK fan from a 5M nation, that I know here, after all.
0
0
© 1998-2025 Shadow Knight Media, LLC. All rights reserved. Mortal Kombat, the dragon logo and all character names are trademarks and copyright of Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.