Cyborg Smoke. Converting him back to flesh is impossible, and would be stupid in my opinion. But both versions rocked.

Since they only existed side by side in UMK3/MKT, I would compare them in that context. Human Smoke owns all, including Cyborg Smoke. Despite being referred to as Human Smoke he is, in actuality, a machine, or more precisely an Instrument of Destruction...(tool for fowl play)

He is also a violent eruption.

Matt

I like cyborg smoke MUCH better...

Human, if he coulda had more of his own moves. But I also believe it would be impossible to turn him back into the human form. If they did they would have to think of a HELL of a story for it.

Eeewwww. Talk about existence dripping away... (yes, you've just gotta love these music lyric jokes :P)

Cyborg smoke even though human has higher combos and is way stronger.Robo looks alot better.Hs palette swap is just to much they could of least tried to give him more detail or something.

I like the human smoke alt of Noob-Smoke in MK:D and his other pic in Shaolin Monks. Other than that I'll go with cyborg Smoke.

Cyborg Smoke only in MKD.

They both have their strong points, fun things, but I gotta go with Inhumane Smoke.

Matt

I prefer Cyborg Smoke, probably cus I'm better with him. I know Human Smoke is more powerful overall (even though they are both top tier) but I just like Robot Smoke more. I think I really liked how he would just appear every now and then on the MK3 select screen, the first time the ? turned around and his avatar was there, I was like

Still, I'm getting better with H. Smoke - trying to learn him, cus he is awesome. Really the are both cool, and either has pluses and negatives. Robot Smoke is just cooler imo...

Oh, and I think it woulda been cool had Ermac and H Smoke had a diferent outfit to the other palette swapped ninjas, in recognition of the fact that they own everyone in the game. Smoke shoulda kept his MK2 outfit, and Ermac coulda had a revamped MK1 outfit, just to show that they dominate

Cyborg Smoke - For the same reasons stated above.

in MKD Noob-Smoke is my 3rd fav to play as. but in the old MK's i hate Smoke. reason is cuz hes nuttin but a rip-off! Human Smoke is just Scorpion but grey and had puffs of smoke. so i dont see y ppl wouldnt rather play as the original, Scorpion. his Cyborg form i like a lot better but still hate. i like Cyber Smoke better cuz he isnt a total rip-off of 1 character. but still hate him cuz hes a rip-off of 4 characters. Scorpion, Reptile, Sektor, and Cyrax.

i use to question y ppl liked Smoke so much? y hes so populare? i mean how can ppl like such a rip-off so darn much? then it came to me. hes like on of the cheapest chars in the old MK's. although i just show those ppl whos boss with Sektor or Ermac.

Always been a fan of human smoke since mk 2 so I would love to see him come back in human form.

I Like Human Smoke better.

I hate cyber smoke, hell I hate all the robots, The Stupid Lin Kuei made them Idiots!

Human Smoke was cool mktrilogy but now hes only robot which sux alot!

have u ppl even seen his alt in MKD? he isnt in Cyborg form in his alt in MKD. its suppose to be his new Human form. although its actually elemental..... and that form i like best. Elemental Smoke all the way!

Liu_Kang187, it is clearly cyborg smoke, human smoke BECAME cyborg smoke after the lin kuei decided to test cybernetic implants on him, cyrax, and sektor. If you read the bios or the story or anything you learn that Noob has captured cyborg smoke and he took him out of the earthrealm to experiment on and try to build an army of cybernetic warriors to take over all the realms.

Human smoke doesn't exist anymore, really he probably wasn't even cannon in umk3, but that doesn't mean he doesn't rock.

So yeah, I'm a much bigger fan of Human Smoke, cyborg smoke makes me sad.