tgrant Wrote: RasAlGhul Wrote: tgrant Wrote: A tournament? I think I know what you have in mind. Explain please. it would consist of taking 64 MK fighters(if we add for example characters from MKSF and MKM(like the water god, earth god etc)we would have 64 fighters. To be fair and make sure that the favorites stays until the end, the last person to be eliminate in the boot and immune thing we just did would face the last person to be eliminated etc, for example Nightwolf would face Kitana, Jade would face Scorpion etc the winner of each matches would be the first one to receive 6 votes. After receiving 6 votes, he would move on to the other round...and so on font>

but how will you work out who to put in each match?

In order for the tournament to be fair, every characetr would have to face off against every other character. I think it shouldn't be done.

yeah I've got some difficulty to explain, I'm french canadian.

lets just say that a part of round 1 for example would be:


1)Nightwolf vs Kitana
2) Sindel vs Jade
3)Scorpion vs Raiden
4)Mileena vs Kenshi

and it would continue like that, people would have to vote for their favorite character in every match and the first character to receive 7 votes would win. it may sound unfair but I'm pretty sure that if Nightwolf would have face someone like Shao Khan or Reptile one on one he would have probably lost

RasAlGhul Wrote: yeah I've got some difficulty to explain, I'm french canadian. lets just say that a part of round 1 for example would be: 1)Nightwolf vs Kitana 2) Sindel vs Jade 3)Scorpion vs Raiden 4)Mileena vs Kenshi and it would continue like that, people would have to vote for their favorite character in every match and the first character to receive 7 votes would win. it may sound unfair but I'm pretty sure that if Nightwolf would have face someone like Shao Khan or Reptile one on one he would have probably lost

That would come down purely to fan favourites and wouldn't be fair at all really. Scorpion vs Sub-Zero would turn out pretty fair but when you do a match like Scorpion vs Khameleon it's obvious who will win. Scorpion would be the favourite but most would probably vote for Khameleon so Scorpion didn't win.

tgrant Wrote: That would come down purely to fan favourites and wouldn't be fair at all really. Scorpion vs Sub-Zero would turn out pretty fair but when you do a match like Scorpion vs Khameleon it's obvious who will win. Scorpion would be the favourite but most would probably vote for Khameleon so Scorpion didn't win.

that remain to be seen lol, or instead of picking 64 characters we could only pick 32 characters and take the ones who are really popular(forget about Meat, Khameleon, earth god, pick only one sub-zero and one smoke etc). But I think that we would have to agree on who is popular and who is not...

I think for example that:

sub-zero
scorpion
sonya
nightwolf
jade
kenshi
raiden
quan chi
cage
kung lao
shao khan
Kitana
baraka
Kabal
Reptile
Frost

just to name a few could be in this 32 people tournament

It's a good idea, but for it to be fair, every character would have to face each other imo and from 32 characters that going to be a LOT of matches! There has to be another way!

Here's an idea. The boot and Immune continues until we have let's say 10 champions. These 10 go head to head in this tournament of yours. Sound good?

tgrant Wrote: It's a good idea, but for it to be fair, every character would have to face each other imo and from 32 characters that going to be a LOT of matches! There has to be another way! Here's an idea. The boot and Immune continues until we have let's say 10 champions. These 10 go head to head in this tournament of yours. Sound good?

I think this is the best way to go. Your right about there being to many characters the other way. The tournement way is a good idea, and would work best for 10 champions out of 32 characters. Then the last one standing will be the undisputed champion. I think tgrant's idea will work best and it also keeps everything fair. So by this logic we already have two of the ten: Sonya and Nightwolf, everytime there is a champ they should not be used in the next game. then when we have ten the tournement can begin so these games are just like preliminaries.

Great! That's one person who agrees! I'll start the new game in a new thread as we can't change the title here.

Thanks TomTaz!

^Not a problem dude.

No! The game should continue here!

Dont make a new thread, this one is goo for the game already!

BTW, Scorpion has to win at least 1!!!

ok I agree, however if we want to do a tournament 10 is not a good number, it should be either 8 or 16.

i agree but let's continue the boot and immune thing here, lets try to reach 10 000 posts lol

RasAlGhul Wrote: ok I agree, however if we want to do a tournament 10 is not a good number, it should be either 8 or 16. i agree but let's continue the boot and immune thing here, lets try to reach 10 000 posts lol

In that case maybe it had better be 16 . What do you think Tgrant?

TomTaz Wrote: RasAlGhul Wrote: ok I agree, however if we want to do a tournament 10 is not a good number, it should be either 8 or 16. i agree but let's continue the boot and immune thing here, lets try to reach 10 000 posts lol In that case maybe it had better be 16 . What do you think Tgrant?

16 is fine!

However I'm going to check with the mods about continuing here. They may have a problem with it.

tgrant Wrote: TomTaz Wrote: RasAlGhul Wrote: ok I agree, however if we want to do a tournament 10 is not a good number, it should be either 8 or 16. i agree but let's continue the boot and immune thing here, lets try to reach 10 000 posts lol In that case maybe it had better be 16 . What do you think Tgrant? 16 is fine! However I'm going to check with the mods about continuing here. They may have a problem with it.

Why?? Its the same game. The same stuff. The same votes. Only that now we will try to get 16 champions but we will continue to vote the same way.

Good idea. How big has the biggest thread been? Or is this it? Hmmm.

wyndrain Wrote: tgrant Wrote: TomTaz Wrote: RasAlGhul Wrote: ok I agree, however if we want to do a tournament 10 is not a good number, it should be either 8 or 16. i agree but let's continue the boot and immune thing here, lets try to reach 10 000 posts lol In that case maybe it had better be 16 . What do you think Tgrant? 16 is fine! However I'm going to check with the mods about continuing here. They may have a problem with it. Why?? Its the same game. The same stuff. The same votes. Only that now we will try to get 16 champions but we will continue to vote the same way.

Because MKSecrets Topic thread got shut down because it was too big. That's why I'm checking.

We should just start up a new game and work on the details of the finals while we’re playing. If the thread is too big I’m sure a mod will let us know and we can move the game to a new one if need be. Someone could PM whoever started this thread and get them to change the thread name to something new. ‘Boot & Immune: Survivor Nether Realm (Game 3)’ for example.

I say we start game 3 or a new game all together. The sooner the better. We need to ask a mod when does a thread become to large and should we start a new thread for game 3.

Why don't we just go ahead and start a new thread to be on the safe side and let this one die out?

i still dont know how all this is gonna work.

i agree however that a new thread should be started

Game 3 shall begin in a new thread!

See you all there!

Game 3, wowI never thought it would gothis far! Lets try and gain the longest post. I immune Cyrax and Boot Sonya. Johnny cage(0,0)
Kano(0,0)
Reptile(0,0)
Sub-Zero(Classic)(0,0)
Sub-Zero(Younger)(0,0)
Sonya(0,1)
Shang Stung(0,0)
Raiden(0,0)
Lui Kang(0,0)
Scorpion(0,0)
Goro(0,0)
Kung Lao(0,0)
Jade(0,0)
Kintaro(0,0)
Kitana(0,0)
Jax(0,0)
Smoke(Human)(0,0)
Smoke(Robot)(0,0)
Shao Kahn(0,0)
Mileena(0,0)
Baraka(0,0)
Noob Saibot(0,0)
Sindel(0,0)
Motaro(0,0)
Stryker(0,0)
Cyrax(1,0)
Sektor(0,0)
NightWolf(0,0)
Sheeva(0,0)
Kabal(0,0)
Rain(0,0)
Ermac(0,0)
Kai(0,0)
Shinnok(0,0)
Reiko(0,0)
Jerek(0,0)
Tanya(0,0)
Fujin(0,0)
Quan Chi(0,0)
Boa Ra Choa(0,0)
Lei Mei(0,0)
Kenshi(0,0)
Mavado(0,0)
Nitaro(0,0)
Drahmin(0,0)
Hsu Hao(0,0)
Frost(0,0)
Moloch(0,0)
Blaze(0,0)
Mokap(0,0)
Cameleon(0,0)
Khameleon(0,0)
Meat(0,0)

tgrant start a new trend blackcyborg