Review on IGN
0
posted11/19/2008 06:09 PM (UTC)by
Avatar
DeathRaiden
Avatar
Member Since
10/01/2005 08:51 PM (UTC)
about what i expected. Still dont like the merging idea.
Avatar
Joe-Von-Zombie
Avatar
About Me

Sig by MINION

11/15/2008 09:34 AM (UTC)
0
My only real complaint with the review is he complains because the Pro Moves are too hard (they're supposed to be) and then has the nerve to call the game shallow. Other than that he could be spot on, ill know tomorrow.
Avatar
Nic-V
11/15/2008 09:54 AM (UTC)
0
Waiting for the Gamespot review for in the excellent words of kiljaeden:
kiljaeden Wrote:
You can't spell ignorant, without IGN!grin
Avatar
kingjolly
11/15/2008 10:16 AM (UTC)
0
Wow...this is a failry negative review, considering IGN gives mk games above 8.0. I usually trust their reviews as well.


I think I might just wait to for the game to get cheap.
Avatar
Detox
Avatar
About Me

You work with what you got...not what you hope for.

11/15/2008 10:41 AM (UTC)
0
Sounds like he would've given it a better score if they had packed the game with content like armageddon, instead of concentrate on what's important.

COME ON SUNDAY!
Avatar
oracle
Avatar
About Me

-sig by MINION

11/15/2008 10:43 AM (UTC)
0
totally called that 7.5 rating.

anyway, i wonder if the pro moves are just too difficult for him to do specifically. because just frame moves that reward skilled players are good. impossible to pull off special moves that are just frustrating are bad.
Avatar
Nic-V
11/15/2008 10:59 AM (UTC)
0
kingjolly Wrote:
Wow...this is a failry negative review, considering IGN gives mk games above 8.0. I usually trust their reviews as well.


I think I might just wait to for the game to get cheap.

Why are you acting like 7.5 is bad? 7.5 is GOOD dude
Avatar
atticus
11/15/2008 11:03 AM (UTC)
0
Anyone click on the video review? Shang's second fatality at the very end, its sooo much better than his first. Go look, NOW
Avatar
oracle
Avatar
About Me

-sig by MINION

11/15/2008 11:17 AM (UTC)
0
Detox Wrote:
Sounds like he would've given it a better score if they had packed the game with content like armageddon, instead of concentrate on what's important.

COME ON SUNDAY!
yeah it couldn't possibly because it plays badly.

so is it hard for shang to turn into someone during gameplay? because it seems pretty quick there with no lag or anything.
Avatar
h1tm0nl33
11/15/2008 11:20 AM (UTC)
0
7.5 the reviews are looking good so far but ign only having a problem with the pro moves is kinda weak it shouldn't matter if the pro moves are hard as long as i can beat the main game without them
Avatar
The-Silencer
11/15/2008 11:27 AM (UTC)
0
Ah! Good review, nice find!

But yes, I'm also a little bit worried about the Pro-Move system.... if it's really that frustrating then it's not worth it. Challenge = ok. Frustration = not ok.
Edit: Did he really say that the pro-moves are hard to pull off? I'm pretty sure that he only mentioned the combo challenge stuff! And that's really a totally different story. Furthermore, he had a lot more to complain (graphics, mini-games etc.).
Avatar
skillz
11/15/2008 01:24 PM (UTC)
0
Hmmm..I've only checked the video review, but it sounds a bit negative. That it's better then before, but still not what it should be. Kinda what I expected. Gonna wait fore more reviews.
Avatar
Zidane_FF
11/15/2008 01:34 PM (UTC)
0
8.5 This is the note for Armageddon

But dont worry, Boon and Co had the talent to make a bad game one after another.
Avatar
ErmaSco
11/15/2008 01:38 PM (UTC)
0
Zidane_FF Wrote:
8.5 This is the note for Armageddon

But dont worry, Boon and Co had the talent to make a bad game one after another.


With all respect ,

Do you really trust IGN ?

Here is your proof you hate Armmageddon while it got 8.5 . Do you think that it deserved it ?

Assasins Greed one of the highly recomanded game got 6.5 on IGN . So having a stupid reviwer to rate a game is something IGN has the talent to do so .

BTW You cant spell IGNorants without IGN can you ?
Avatar
Zidane_FF
11/15/2008 01:48 PM (UTC)
0
I dont trust any review

But Midway and other enterprises do.

Remember all those high scores that MK Deception receive. They all over the main page of the website.

Now, how Midway will put a score like this and could be proud? I would not.
Avatar
SubMan799
11/15/2008 03:04 PM (UTC)
0
IGN is my favorite video game site. This review is a bit disapointing. I'm still getting it though
Avatar
The-Silencer
11/15/2008 03:25 PM (UTC)
0
Reviews are not meant to be the deciding factor for the readers / viewers. They are only one opinion out of many others. It has nothing to do with trust. Therefore, It doesn't make any difference if you read or watch one review or thousands. If you wanna buy the game or not is up to you and no one else. And moreover, it's really just a matter of taste, but that's understood. (For example: I really like Killer7!).

So, I don't understand all the fuss about negative or good reviews and stuff. Of course, you can use reviews as some kind of guideline, but like I said before it makes no difference if you read them or not.
Avatar
elmon
11/15/2008 03:37 PM (UTC)
0
The-Silencer Wrote:
Reviews are not meant to be the deciding factor for the readers / viewers. They are only one opinion out of many others. It has nothing to do with trust. Therefore, It doesn't make any difference if you read or watch one review or thousands. If you wanna buy the game or not is up to you and no one else. And moreover, it's really just a matter of taste, but that's understood. (For example: I really like Killer7!).

So, I don't understand all the fuss about negative or good reviews and stuff. Of course, you can use reviews as some kind of guideline, but like I said before it makes no difference if you read them or not.


Totally agree with you. Reviews are only opinions, someone might review this game and give it a 9.5, meaning it's damn near perfect, so someone will go picking it up thinking its a damn near perfect game, only to be dissapointed. You might find your own reasons for not liking the game. Thats why I don't put much stock into reviews, I'll decide for myself wheter or not I like a game.

As for Mk Vs. DC, I'm gonna do what I always do, rent it first, and if i like it, I'll buy it.
Avatar
Garlador
11/15/2008 03:55 PM (UTC)
0
Greg Miller has played the game, thoroughly it seems, and his glorified opinion is that it's a 7.5 game, which is generally favorable but not impressive.

And he's absolutely right.

So's the guy or girl who thinks this game is a 10/10 or a 2/10 endeavor.

Alot of what he said I've had problems with. While I don't mind the lack of unlockable content, you know it IS kind of a bummer it all got axed. Meanwhile, the gameplay still is Mortal Kombat, for better or worse. I'm not a fan of any of the gimmicks in this game (FreeFall, Klose Kombat, or Rage) except Test Your Might, and it was said that's only used in 3 out of 14 stages.

The difficult combos, enough to frustrate some to the point of giving up, doesn't sound like a very good control scheme if that's the case. I mean, I've played plenty of fighters, and even I can pull off incredibly difficult strung-together moves given enough info, timing, and training, but it sounds like the game has a problem telling the player when they should continue their combos, making it a guessing game.

I don't know yet. I'll wait for more reviews, but currently 7.5 is about where my expectations are for this game. Not bad by any means, but not the high-bar quality I keep demanding.
Avatar
h1tm0nl33
11/15/2008 04:11 PM (UTC)
0
now I'm just wonder what psm and game informer are gonna give it
Avatar
jbthrash
11/15/2008 04:24 PM (UTC)
0
I thought this was a pretty good review. It wasn't bias, and he gave his reasons for why he gave it a 7.5. I'm sure I will like it a lot more than him, and I don't think one review should be the deciding factor of buying the game.
Avatar
kingjolly
11/15/2008 04:32 PM (UTC)
0
But the thing is, IGN is very lenient on their reviews. They usually score higher than alot of other sites. If IGN gave the game a 7.5, I bet Gamespot is going to give the game a 7.0.
Avatar
jbthrash
11/15/2008 04:34 PM (UTC)
0
I think Gametrailers will give it a higher review, because they take story into consideration, and most fighting games ignore the story.
Pages: 2
Discord
Twitch
Twitter
YouTube
Facebook
Privacy Policy
© 1998-2025 Shadow Knight Media, LLC. All rights reserved. Mortal Kombat, the dragon logo and all character names are trademarks and copyright of Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.