Does DC have the chops to keep up with MK? (Not a dig at DC)
0
posted04/22/2008 09:10 PM (UTC)by
Avatar
Oni Lord Asmodeus
Avatar
About Me

Member Since
02/19/2003 09:41 PM (UTC)
I've been thinking and reading, and talking to people, some DC fans, and I I'm really starting to wonder if DC has the skill to take down MK.

Sure people point to superman and/or someone like darksied and from that overall perspective, the DC universe has a huge advantage in terms of raw power. But on an even play field does the skill of the MK fighters just demolish DC's?

Take batman for instance. An acomplished martial artist in his own right, a gret detective giving him great insight and the ability to size up apponents easily and deduce weaknesses very quickly. Pound for pound, he is DC's greatest warrior but because he is not invulerable, because he is human, he is automaticly outclassed by his counter-parts.

If you look at it from that perspective, MK has an army of batmen as each of the Kombatants are the cream of the crop from there respective realms and each has been acknowledged as such. just like batman, pound for pound, these guys and girls bring A LOT to the table.

but those are just the human characters, the likes for Kahn, Onaga, Shinnok, Raiden, etc. up the antie quite a bit.

Look at superman. It was put to me that superman is so great that not only his physical strength is off the charts but so is his mental strength. He has to dumb himself down just to interact with humans and because of that, he has put limitations on himself just to fit in. Cotrast that to Raiden or some of the other super-human characters in MK.

A god character in MK has the wisdom and experience of the ages at their finger tips. Just like Supes, in order for them to fight along side humans or mortals they have to dumb themselves down...a lot. So much so that they take on the weaknesses and frailties that mortals inherantly possess. Raiden anyone.

Let Raiden loose on Darksied, it wouldn't be as lopsided as some might think. Let Kahn go toe to toe with Supes, I think the man of steels soul would belong to Emperor. and so on and so forth, the match-ups are their. Some say bats can take Zero hands down, I don't think I'm over estimating the Lin Kuei Grandmaster's skill and experience when I say that they are at least on the same level as Batman, and that his Kori powers just sweeten the pot.

Bottom line, the MK fighters are bred killing machines. They are the best of the best not only in terms of skill but knowledge and power.

Oh and for another example just look into the Karate Kid, the DC character that is. His skill as a fighter, I would say is parallel to Cage's, he is just extremely skilled and not much else.

I read that "Val" took on superboy and out skilled him on every level but because superboy is invulnerable and has super reflexes, nothing to do with skill, the Karate kid lost.

On an even playfield, like we will see in MK Vs DC, MK will win with a "Supreme Victory!".
Avatar
MoodyShooter
Avatar
About Me

Dedicated, hopeless...Li Mei fan.

04/22/2008 02:21 AM (UTC)
0
Actually I think the big question is does MK have the chops to keep up with DC?
Avatar
Shin_Akuma
04/22/2008 02:26 AM (UTC)
0
The_Truth Wrote:
Actually I think the big question is does MK have the chops to keep up with DC?

It will be amazing if MK ever reaches even close to DC.

MK is full of ruthless killing machines, DC is filled with the perfect embodiment of justice; they won't kill those who are out to kill them. Which makes an MK vs DC crossover all the better, and more plausible; Because these two sets of warriors were brought up in completley different realms and enviornments, they don't know how to react to each other. So obviously since they're different and mysterious they're interpreted as a threat.
Avatar
Leo
Avatar
About Me

04/22/2008 02:28 AM (UTC)
0
Nice starter post, and some great points. I'll have to think about that one, but either way, I'm hoping MK kicks all asses.
Avatar
kuczy
04/22/2008 02:29 AM (UTC)
0
I think Doomsday will " have the chops" and then some. When the game was announced I was pissed but, now I think it could be very interesting. The DC universe is huge not just a Superman/ Batman universe.
Avatar
AcEs777
04/22/2008 02:30 AM (UTC)
0
finally a soul who sees that there is more 2 fighting with raw power so in your well thought essay about mk being more capable in the battle field then dc wow
Avatar
Oni Lord Asmodeus
04/22/2008 02:59 AM (UTC)
0
kuczy Wrote:
I think Doomsday will " have the chops" and then some. When the game was announced I was pissed but, now I think it could be very interesting. The DC universe is huge not just a Superman/ Batman universe.


And see this is what I talking about. Why and how does he have the chops? because he can take a punch? because he can dish it out?

Put Shinnok against Doomsday? Remember shinnok isn't bound to any form. Shinnok, or any other god character in MK, make doomsday a non issue.


The_Truth Wrote:
Actually I think the big question is does MK have the chops to keep up with DC?


Keeping in mind that even match-ups are paramount, give some examples of DC characters who just out class that MK characters.
Avatar
XiahouDun84
04/22/2008 03:03 AM (UTC)
0
One character I know can match up to MK's heavy hitters in terms of power and skill is Wonder Woman. She's got Superman-level power, is one of DC's best fighters, and has strong defence againt magic.

But I think something to consider is just how powerful are MK's most powerful? Take Shao Kahn for instance. Liu Kang was able to defeat him. So is Liu Kang therefore a match for Superman?
Avatar
Oni Lord Asmodeus
04/22/2008 03:28 AM (UTC)
0
But liu beat Kahn under "special circumstances," ie, the Invasion. The merger had all types of advese affect to character during that time (just like I suspect it will in MK Vs DC), I don't think Kahn was an acception.

but yeah, if Supes and Kang fought in outworld or some other place where Supes didn't have an unlimited source of power (the sun) then yes Kang could hold his own. Being the Leader of the Earthrealm fighters, and his skills being acknowledged as the best within the MK universe, pound for pound, I think Kang is better than supes.

I could be way off. please someone show me a situation where Supes has not only out smarted an opponent, but out skilled them. Everything I've seen shows Supes trying to beat an opponent with pure brute strength, ie doomsday, darksied, metallo.

But to your wonder woman point...yes she is very powerful and skillful, she is definitely not just a "strong man" character, she has depth. But given her strength, she would be on par with the god charcters of MK. Let's say Taven was on her strength level. Knowing Taven can beat raiden one on one, and can even take Fujin, do you think Taven could hold his own, maybe even win against Diana?
Avatar
kuczy
04/22/2008 03:34 AM (UTC)
0
Read this with an open mind, it's long. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_(comics)

Are you saying me that Doomsday could not be in MK?What makes his story so different from the MK stories? Sub in some MK names and we would eat him up as a sub-bossand think Boon was a genius. I think the way you use your logic on Shinnok makes everyone short of the gods in MK irrelevant. Case in point how could Jonny Cage or Nightwolf (My personal fav.) ever defeat Shinnok?? How is Lui Kang the hero almost every game?
Boon said 20 or 22 of the most popular 10 or 11 from both sides and I don't think Shinnok will make it anyway.
Look in the 30sec trailer you see probly 10sec of fighting or less. We will see is 7 months or so.

I not in love with Doomsday or anyone else in DC for that matter but, I was supprised at how dark some in DC are.
Avatar
XiahouDun84
04/22/2008 03:38 AM (UTC)
0
asmodeus Wrote:
But to your wonder woman point...yes she is very powerful and skillful, she is definitely not just a "strong man" character, she has depth. But given her strength, she would be on par with the god charcters of MK. Let's say Taven was on her strength level. Knowing Taven can beat raiden one on one, and can even take Fujin, do you think Taven could hold his own, maybe even win against Diana?

If we're accepting Taven as that strong...yes, he could probably match her. But then it would come down to skill, experience, and discipline. And in those categories, I think Diana has the advantage.
Avatar
Oni Lord Asmodeus
04/22/2008 03:44 AM (UTC)
0
kuczy Wrote:
Read this with an open mind, it's long. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_(comics)

Are you saying me that Doomsday could not be in MK?What makes his story so different from the MK stories? Sub in some MK names and we would eat him up as a sub-bossand think Boon was a genius. I think the way you use your logic on Shinnok makes everyone short of the gods in MK irrelevant. Case in point how could Jonny Cage or Nightwolf (My personal fav.) ever defeat Shinnok?? How is Lui Kang the hero almost every game?
Boon said 20 or 22 of the most popular 10 or 11 from both sides and I don't think Shinnok will make it anyway.
Look in the 30sec trailer you see probly 10sec of fighting or less. We will see is 7 months or so.

I not in love with Doomsday or anyone else in DC for that matter but, I was supprised at how dark some in DC are.


this is not a discussion on whether or not doomsday or any other DC character would fit in the MK universe, or how "dark" they are. And I don't think I said that shinnok makes anyone irrelevant.

Remember knowlege is power.

I don't know how Shinnok was defeated in MK4, some say liu, I say Raiden, but one thing for sure, it wasn't Cage and if Nightwolf was there he would have been turn inside out. and I'm not talking god powers, nightwolf, IMO, doesn't have what it takes. it's a stratch for me to believe Kang could do it.

buy yeah, this thread is about skill and match-ups. Can Doomsday defeat, kill an Elder God? Doomsday couldn't even touch an Elder God.
Avatar
Oni Lord Asmodeus
04/22/2008 03:46 AM (UTC)
0
XiahouDun84 Wrote:
asmodeus Wrote:
But to your wonder woman point...yes she is very powerful and skillful, she is definitely not just a "strong man" character, she has depth. But given her strength, she would be on par with the god charcters of MK. Let's say Taven was on her strength level. Knowing Taven can beat raiden one on one, and can even take Fujin, do you think Taven could hold his own, maybe even win against Diana?

If we're accepting Taven as that strong...yes, he could probably match her. But then it would come down to skill, experience, and discipline. And in those categories, I think Diana has the advantage.


point taken.
Avatar
kuczy
04/22/2008 03:50 AM (UTC)
0
FYI: During the final stages of this war, Raiden was forced to choose between sacrificing Earth's indigenous races, or ceding the rule of Earthrealm to Shinnok. The angered Elder Gods intervened and assisted Raiden in his struggle. Raiden defeated Shinnok and stripped him of his amulet. Shinnok was then banished to the deepest regions of the Netherealm.

Avatar
Oni Lord Asmodeus
04/22/2008 03:53 AM (UTC)
0
kuczy Wrote:
FYI: During the final stages of this war, Raiden was forced to choose between sacrificing Earth's indigenous races, or ceding the rule of Earthrealm to Shinnok. The angered Elder Gods intervened and assisted Raiden in his struggle. Raiden defeated Shinnok and stripped him of his amulet. Shinnok was then banished to the deepest regions of the Netherealm.



OK?
Avatar
Mick-Lucifer
Avatar
About Me

What do you like? Hit the Toasty thumbs up on articles and forum posts for a quick response!
04/22/2008 06:27 AM (UTC)
0
asmodeus Wrote:
Take batman for instance. An acomplished martial artist in his own right, a gret detective giving him great insight and the ability to size up apponents easily and deduce weaknesses very quickly. Pound for pound, he is DC's greatest warrior but because he is not invulerable, because he is human, he is automaticly outclassed by his counter-parts.

In the context of Batman, this is a contradiction. His deduction of weaknesses and fighting prowess are exactly why he's often regarded the most overpowered character in DC comics.

The overall point is definitely fair, though.
DC's biggest heroes are far more reliant on powers than fighting skills.

Of the big seven most likely to appear, Batman and Wonder Woman are your best hand-to-hand fighters. Superman, Flash, Green Lantern, Aquaman, and Martian Manhunter aren't typically characterized for those skills, though that goes to varying degrees. Hawkgirl (or Hawkman) could bring up the rear, assuming the mainstream success of the cartoons makes her a strong candidate.

Of course, if there was going to be a wider selection than just ten or eleven from each, you could open your options more to better match-ups, even on MK terms (ie; round 1).
Avatar
tgrant
Avatar
About Me
Project MKK: Coming soon...

Currently working on: MKD & MKA - The One Ring Theory
04/22/2008 06:39 AM (UTC)
0
Interesting thread. I agree that MK characters like Raiden do dumb themsleves down in MK and that's one of the things I dislike. The example of Superman is simialr but when eh fights, he can let loose. Raiden cannot as he's still in human form which makes me wonder if he and the other gods have another form where they would be at their normal strength and most powerful.
Anyway, the likes of Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman I assume would definitely be able to hold their own versus many of MK's warriors. I think some of them have that extra thing that makes them slightly more formidable. Experience and knowledge will go a long way and I think many of the fighters on either side would be Now I think about it, Shujinko would probably be the one doing alot of the ass kicking if he were in the game given his ability and Taven would be a good candidate given his own achievements as asmodeus mentioned.
Avatar
You-Know-Who
04/22/2008 02:37 PM (UTC)
0
I think Doomsday would not only be able to touch an Elder God, but could potentially kill him. That thing is a beast of destruction, baby. Beyond any mortal comprehension.

I get what this thread is trying to say, but the reaction my dad had when I told him about this game, was "Superman would beat them all, wouldn't he?" Like it's a non-issue to even have the game.

Wonder Woman, Superman, Doomsday, Darkseid and a few of the more powerful characters like that would make great foils for Raiden, Shao Kahn and the like.

More human characters like Batman and Catwoman would match up well against experienced martial artists like Liu Kang and Kitana.

I'm sorry, but even as a much bigger fan of MK than DC, I can not imagine Liu Kang faring too well against Superman. I think the best explanation you could give is some sort of gimmick involving Liu Kang's chi enabling him to kick Superman around.
Avatar
PANOS_SOFOS
04/22/2008 06:56 PM (UTC)
0
Superman is weak against two things kryptonite and magic. When the merge of the universes occurs he will be weakened, and the MK characters will power up so, there's gonna be a ballance!
Avatar
V1LLA1N
Avatar
About Me

Im banned from mko

04/22/2008 07:21 PM (UTC)
0
Only character from DC who would actually take down MK would be Superman.
Avatar
ThePredator151
Avatar
About Me
The Ultimate Mortal Kombat Experience
- Lead Graphic Designer - Mortal Kombat Online -


:G-play

:Story

:F-Design

:Cutout

:Get Sig

:Raiden

:Fans [1] [2]

:#LegendaryArts

04/22/2008 08:16 PM (UTC)
0
I swear i was just having this conversation with my cousin yesterday.

We came to a couple of realizations.

1. This is exactly why we should have power scales//grids or something like it in MK. Something that gauges the experience of MK characters and so on...I'd even say something simple like the Character Profiles that we used to have would be enough. Age, weight, Height...origin that sort of thing.

2. There are slim to none of the main well known characters of the DC universe, that would fair well against MK's Universe....under the presence of "conditions"

Whoever said it first, Batman and Wonder Woman. There you go, they're about it from DC.

3. Mortal Kombat doesn't benefit from the vs game, unless we get to win, or stalemate them in the story or something. Think about it, unless we win the fight, we take the hit for the T rating and no fatalities and all that just because they're DC.

So I deduce, that since we can't kill them, we almost have to be able to win the fight.....Cuz the playing field is not even, AND cuz, we're simply, more skilled killing machines than they are. It's all we do on the MK-side. I think DC needs to prove to a wider-younger audience, that they still have the "chops"...even though the information is there to prove it's true regardless. So, they wanna get in the dirtiest fighting game in the genre, and show everybody that they can in fact get dirty too.

But anyway, not enough of the DC characters are skilled enough to win under the circumstances MK vs DC present. Magic, almost automatically reduce a vast majority of the JL to defeat-able, capture-able, and even kill-able.

So, we'll either stalemate the DC characters, or we'd win.

Another interesting perspective is What the MK characters are capable of, on the DC side of this..."merger". Nothing so far that I've seen, heard, or read says that the MK characters will suffer somehow, from being over there. But there's two story sides supposed to be in this game right?

If I take Raiden over there, he'd still kick a bunch of ass. He's being matched up with Doomsday or Darkseid(can't remember) and both of those characters kick Superman's ass all over the place. Especially if this contest doesn't warrant that Raiden surrender his normal form for human form. Even though he can look the same in either celestial, or human form.

He'd give all three of those characters an extremely tough time if they think they'd "just win", and want to fight one on one....on their turf. And on top of that, he'd keep coming back....he has all eternity behind him, and in front of him.....

The catch..The thing is, with these extremely powerful characters.... it's always geographically sensitive. "Where" they can have the power they have...Raiden is reluctant to stay on Outworld. Which is where the MK side of this, seems to be set...*shrugs* So what would this "merger" do to Raiden? Reduce him further on THAT realm, or make geography irrelevant?

We need power levels//gauges//scales, or at least background information that informs us of skill, experience, knowledge and wisdom for both sides of this thing.

That's my thought on it though..
Avatar
-Brad-
04/22/2008 09:10 PM (UTC)
0
The big problem with MK is vagueness.

Just how powerful are the mk gods.

It’s not confirmed at all Raiden’s or Fujin’s true form is any more powerful than their human form. But it is confirmed the original Sub-Zero defeated the fire god/water god/earth god and Fujin (had no reason to fight Raiden). That to me throws a monkey wrench in what I used to think.

Just how powerful is Scorpion:
- He can teleport, how far? And where to?
- It’s showed he can teleport his opponent to the netherrealm, this would cause him to gain strength while his opponent loses. Who can/can’t this be done to?
- He can summon hellfire, limitless? And how exactly?


On a lot of sites around the net, I think MK is being pretty damn underestimated (not here so much). They’re almost on level ground already.
Pages: 1
Discord
Twitch
Twitter
YouTube
Facebook
Privacy Policy
© 1998-2025 Shadow Knight Media, LLC. All rights reserved. Mortal Kombat, the dragon logo and all character names are trademarks and copyright of Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.